SG Bank Loan

A smaller monthly payment is not the same as a saving.

Stretch a loan over more months and the monthly figure falls even if the rate does not improve at all. Sometimes refinancing genuinely saves money. Sometimes it just moves the cost somewhere you are not looking. This works out which one you are being offered.

Staying put against refinancing, over the life of the loanStaying put costs S$206,062 over the life of the loan and refinancing costs S$215,853, a difference of S$9,791.
Stay
S$206,062
Switch
S$215,853
Extra if you switch
S$9,791
Both bars are the total paid over the whole tenure, fees included, not the monthly payment. Change the inputs below and this redraws.


Monthly now

Monthly if you switch

Total left to pay now

Total if you switch, fees included

Lifetime difference

The rate an offer has to beat

The question a business owner actually has is not "is this offer any good". It is "how good would an offer have to be". That has an exact answer, and it depends almost entirely on the tenure being offered rather than on the rate. Every figure below is worked out from the balance, rate and switching cost you entered above.

The highest rate at which refinancing still does not cost more, by the tenure offered, at the balance and switching cost entered above
Tenure offeredMonthly paymentRate it must beat
24 monthsS$8,50312.35%
36 monthsS$5,6688.33%
48 monthsS$4,2516.29%
60 monthsS$3,4015.05%
72 monthsS$2,8344.22%

When the fee is larger than the interest you have left

This is the case worth checking before any other. Late in a business loan almost every dollar of the instalment is repaying principal, so the interest still ahead of you can be small. Once the cost of moving is larger than that, no rate any lender in Singapore can quote makes switching cheaper, because there is no longer enough interest left to save. The arithmetic settles it and no negotiation changes it.

The question to ask

Not "what is the new monthly payment". Ask what the total is, over the whole tenure, with every fee counted. If a refinance is genuinely better it will still look better on that number. If someone changes the subject back to the monthly figure, you have your answer.

Check whether the new rate is flat or an EIR

Thinking about moving a loan? Send us the numbers

A sentence or two is enough. You will get a straight answer about whether it is worth applying, including when the answer is that it is not.

Leave this blank and we will simply reply by email.

    We are an independent consultancy. We do not lend, and sending this does not apply for anything or commit you to anything.